Scala Inheritance of Type Constructor

Question

Right now, I am trying to implement a variant of a Linked List with the following code, but I am having trouble with it. Basically, I am trying to create different type of nodes that will connect with each other by the next method. Thus, I have two classes, NodeA[T] and NodeB[T], that inherited from the abstract class, NodeTrait[T]. I just want next to be any type that is a subtype of NodeTrait[T] and is contained in Option. Thus, I want next to be either the type Option[NodeA[T]] or Option[NodeB[T]].

However, I get a compiler error saying expression of type Option[NodeTrait[T]] doesn't confirm to expected type NodeTrait[T]. I am not exactly sure how to solve this problem. I was thinking about using covariance and change NodeTrait[T] to NodeTrait[+T] but I still get more compiling errors. Does anybody have any tips to solve this issue?

abstract class NodeTrait[T](x:T) {
  var next:Option[NodeTrait[T]]
  def insert(y: T):Option[NodeTrait[T]]
}



class NodeA[T](x:T) extends  NodeTrait[T](x){
  def insert(y: T): NodeTrait[T] = {
    val newnode = new NodeA[T](y)
    next = Some(new NodeA[T](y))
    next
  }
  next = None

}

class NodeB[T](x:T) extends  NodeTrait[T](x){
  def insert(y: T): NodeTrait[T] = {
    val newnode = new NodeB[T](y)
    next = Some(new NodeB[T](y))
    next
  }
  next = None



}

Tyth · Accepted Answer · 2015-08-25 14:44:49Z

3

I don't know what your code do, lets assume it's just simplified abstract version of something, but here edited code that compiles:

abstract class NodeTrait[T](x:T) {
  var next:Option[NodeTrait[T]]
  def insert(y: T):Option[NodeTrait[T]]
}


class NodeA[T](x:T) extends  NodeTrait[T](x){
  def insert(y: T): Option[NodeTrait[T]] = {
    val newnode = new NodeA[T](y)
    next = Some(new NodeA[T](y))
    next
  }
  var next: Option[NodeTrait[T]] = None

}

class NodeB[T](x:T) extends  NodeTrait[T](x){
  def insert(y: T): Option[NodeTrait[T]] = {
    val newnode = new NodeB[T](y)
    next = Some(new NodeB[T](y))
    next
  }

 var next: Option[NodeTrait[T]] = None
}

You specified different (from NodeTrait) return types in you NodeB and NodeA insert method.

answered Aug 25, 2015 at 14:44

Tyth

1,8241 gold badge12 silver badges17 bronze badges

Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

Scala Inheritance of Type Constructor

1 Answer 1

Comments

Your Answer

Hot Network Questions

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

1 Answer 1

Comments

Your Answer

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Related