Consider the code below:
#include <utility>
void f(int, int);
void g(int, int);
struct functor
{
template<typename... T>
void operator()(T&&... params)
{
return f(std::forward<T>(params)...);
}
};
int main()
{
functor()(1); // can use the default value here, why?!
// g(1); // error here as expected, too few arguments
}
void f(int a, int b = 42) {}
void g(int a, int b = 24) {}
This is a thin wrapper around a function call. However, inside functor::operator(), f doesn't have its default value for the second parameter known (it is visible only after main, in the definition), so the code should not compile. g++5.2 compiles it successfully though, but clang++ spits out the expected message that one expects for compilers that perform the two-phase name lookup correctly:
error: call to function 'f' that is neither visible in the template definition nor found by argument-dependent lookup return f(std::forward(params)...);
Is this a gcc bug or I am missing something here? I.e., is the point of instantiation after the definition of f below main()? But even in this case, it shouldn't work, as at the second phase the function can only be found via ADL, which is not the case here.
fwith default parameter is visible... Wonder if the program is not ill-formed...fitself was found before, and now the definition with the default param is visible. The definition is not other function, it's just the same function.