For the past couple of hours I've been trying to track down a bug in my program, which only occurs when running it in release mode. I've already resolved all level-4 compiler-warnings, and there are no uninitialized variables anywhere (Which would usually be my first suspect in a case like this).
This is a tough one to explain, since I don't even exactly know what exactly is going on, so bear with me please.
After a lot of debugging, I've narrowed the cause of the bug down to somewhere in the following function:
void CModelSubMesh::Update()
{
ModelSubMesh::Update();
auto bHasAlphas = (GetAlphaCount() > 0) ? true : false;
auto bAnimated = (!m_vertexWeights.empty() || !m_weightBoneIDs.empty()) ? true : false;
if(bHasAlphas == false && bAnimated == false)
m_glMeshData = std::make_unique<GLMeshData>(m_vertices,m_normals,m_uvs,m_triangles);
else
{
m_glmesh = GLMesh();
auto bufVertex = OpenGL::GenerateBuffer();
auto bufUV = OpenGL::GenerateBuffer();
auto bufNormal = OpenGL::GenerateBuffer();
auto bufIndices = OpenGL::GenerateBuffer();
auto bufAlphas = 0;
if(bHasAlphas == true)
bufAlphas = OpenGL::GenerateBuffer();
auto vao = OpenGL::GenerateVertexArray();
m_glmesh.SetVertexArrayObject(vao);
m_glmesh.SetVertexBuffer(bufVertex);
m_glmesh.SetUVBuffer(bufUV);
m_glmesh.SetNormalBuffer(bufNormal);
if(bHasAlphas == true)
m_glmesh.SetAlphaBuffer(bufAlphas);
m_glmesh.SetIndexBuffer(bufIndices);
m_glmesh.SetVertexCount(CUInt32(m_vertices.size()));
auto numTriangles = CUInt32(m_triangles.size()); // CUInt32 is equivalent to static_cast<unsigned int>
m_glmesh.SetTriangleCount(numTriangles);
// PLACEHOLDER LINE
OpenGL::BindVertexArray(vao);
OpenGL::BindBuffer(bufVertex,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::BindBufferData(CInt32(m_vertices.size()) *sizeof(glm::vec3),&m_vertices[0],GL_STATIC_DRAW,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::EnableVertexAttribArray(SHADER_VERTEX_BUFFER_LOCATION);
OpenGL::SetVertexAttribData(
SHADER_VERTEX_BUFFER_LOCATION,
3,
GL_FLOAT,
GL_FALSE,
(void*)0
);
OpenGL::BindBuffer(bufUV,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::BindBufferData(CInt32(m_uvs.size()) *sizeof(glm::vec2),&m_uvs[0],GL_STATIC_DRAW,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::EnableVertexAttribArray(SHADER_UV_BUFFER_LOCATION);
OpenGL::SetVertexAttribData(
SHADER_UV_BUFFER_LOCATION,
2,
GL_FLOAT,
GL_FALSE,
(void*)0
);
OpenGL::BindBuffer(bufNormal,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::BindBufferData(CInt32(m_normals.size()) *sizeof(glm::vec3),&m_normals[0],GL_STATIC_DRAW,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::EnableVertexAttribArray(SHADER_NORMAL_BUFFER_LOCATION);
OpenGL::SetVertexAttribData(
SHADER_NORMAL_BUFFER_LOCATION,
3,
GL_FLOAT,
GL_FALSE,
(void*)0
);
if(!m_vertexWeights.empty())
{
m_bufVertWeights.bufWeights = OpenGL::GenerateBuffer();
OpenGL::BindBuffer(m_bufVertWeights.bufWeights,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::BindBufferData(CInt32(m_vertexWeights.size()) *sizeof(float),&m_vertexWeights[0],GL_STATIC_DRAW,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::EnableVertexAttribArray(SHADER_BONE_WEIGHT_LOCATION);
OpenGL::BindBuffer(m_bufVertWeights.bufWeights,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::SetVertexAttribData(
SHADER_BONE_WEIGHT_LOCATION,
4,
GL_FLOAT,
GL_FALSE,
(void*)0
);
}
if(!m_weightBoneIDs.empty())
{
m_bufVertWeights.bufBoneIDs = OpenGL::GenerateBuffer();
OpenGL::BindBuffer(m_bufVertWeights.bufBoneIDs,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::BindBufferData(CInt32(m_weightBoneIDs.size()) *sizeof(int),&m_weightBoneIDs[0],GL_STATIC_DRAW,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::EnableVertexAttribArray(SHADER_BONE_WEIGHT_ID_LOCATION);
OpenGL::BindBuffer(m_bufVertWeights.bufBoneIDs,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
glVertexAttribIPointer(
SHADER_BONE_WEIGHT_ID_LOCATION,
4,
GL_INT,
0,
(void*)0
);
}
if(bHasAlphas == true)
{
OpenGL::BindBuffer(bufAlphas,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::BindBufferData(CInt32(m_alphas.size()) *sizeof(glm::vec2),&m_alphas[0],GL_STATIC_DRAW,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::EnableVertexAttribArray(SHADER_USER_BUFFER1_LOCATION);
OpenGL::SetVertexAttribData(
SHADER_USER_BUFFER1_LOCATION,
2,
GL_FLOAT,
GL_FALSE,
(void*)0
);
}
OpenGL::BindBuffer(bufIndices,GL_ELEMENT_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::BindBufferData(numTriangles *sizeof(unsigned int),&m_triangles[0],GL_STATIC_DRAW,GL_ELEMENT_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::BindVertexArray(0);
OpenGL::BindBuffer(0,GL_ARRAY_BUFFER);
OpenGL::BindBuffer(0,GL_ELEMENT_ARRAY_BUFFER);
}
ComputeTangentBasis(m_vertices,m_uvs,m_normals,m_triangles);
}
My program is a graphics application, and this piece of code generates the object buffers which are required for rendering later on. The bug basically causes the vertices of a specific mesh to be rendered incorrectly when certain conditions are met. The bug is consistent and happens every time for the same mesh.
Sadly I can't narrow the code down any further, since that would make the bug disappear, and explaining what each line does would take quite a while and isn't too relevant here. I'm almost positive that this is a problem with compiler optimization, so the actual bug is more of a side-effect in this case anyway.
With the code above, the bug will occur, but only when in release mode. The interesting part is the line I marked as "PLACEHOLDER LINE".
If I change the code to one of the following 3 variants, the bug will disappear:
#1:
void CModelSubMesh::Update()
{
[...]
// PLACEHOLDER LINE
std::cout<<numTriangles<<std::endl;
[...]
}
#2:
#pragma optimize( "", off )
void CModelSubMesh::Update()
{
[...] // No changes to the code
}
#pragma optimize( "", on )
#3:
static void test()
{
auto *f = new float; // Do something to make sure the compiler doesn't optimize this function away; Doesn't matter what
delete f;
}
void CModelSubMesh::Update()
{
[...]
// PLACEHOLDER LINE
test()
[...]
}
Especially variant #2 indicates that something is being optimized which shouldn't be.
I don't expect anyone to magically know what the root of the problem is, since that would require deeper knowledge of the code. However, maybe someone with a better understanding of the compiler optimization process can give me some hints, what could be going on here?
Since almost any change to the code gets rid of the bug, I'm just not sure what I can do to actually find the cause of it.
bHasAlpha, seems like a good start)