62

I have a lot of functions that either have type hinting for arrays or use is_array() to check the array-ness of a variable.

Now I'm starting to use objects that are iterable. They implement Iterator or IteratorAggregate. Will these be accepted as arrays if they pass through type hinting, or undergo is_array()?

If I have to modify my code, is there a generic sort of is_iterable(), or must I do something like:

if ( is_array($var) OR $var instance_of Iterable OR $var instanceof IteratorAggregate ) { ... }

What other iterable interfaces are out there?

6 Answers 6

77

I think you mean instanceof Iterator, PHP doesn't have an Iterable interface. It does have a Traversable interface though. Iterator and IteratorAggregate both extend Traversable (and AFAIK they are the only ones to do so).

But no, objects implementing Traversable won't pass the is_array() check, nor there is a built-in is_iterable() function. A check you could use is

function is_iterable($var) {
    return (is_array($var) || $var instanceof Traversable);
}

To be clear, all php objects can be iterated with foreach, but only some of them implement Traversable. The presented is_iterable function will therefore not detect all things that foreach can handle.

Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

5 Comments

Iterator and IteratorAggregate don't implement Traversable. They are interfaces and as such have no implementation. They extend Traversable. Other than that, +1
I can not see what I am doing wrong, but it doesn't seem to work for classes which are fine with foreach: codepad.org/hi373LYg
foreach will work with classes which aren't instances of those interfaces. It just iterates through all properties of the instance. If you want custom behavior you'll have to implement Iterator
PHP has the pseudo type iterable now (7.1). :-D
@NullUserException as PHP7.1 implements the is_iterable function already, you should add and if function_exists(...) to your example code
40

PHP 7.1.0 has introduced the iterable pseudo-type and the is_iterable() function, which is specially designed for such a purpose:

This […] proposes a new iterable pseudo-type. This type is analogous to callable, accepting multiple types instead of one single type.

iterable accepts any array or object implementing Traversable. Both of these types are iterable using foreach and can be used with yield from within a generator.

function foo(iterable $iterable) {
    foreach ($iterable as $value) {
        // ...
    }
}

This […] also adds a function is_iterable() that returns a boolean: true if a value is iterable and will be accepted by the iterable pseudo-type, false for other values.

var_dump(is_iterable([1, 2, 3])); // bool(true)
var_dump(is_iterable(new ArrayIterator([1, 2, 3]))); // bool(true)
var_dump(is_iterable((function () { yield 1; })())); // bool(true)
var_dump(is_iterable(1)); // bool(false)
var_dump(is_iterable(new stdClass())); // bool(false)

1 Comment

seems odd that it should be false for stdClass as you can iterate over them with foreach same as an array. I often use arrays and basic objects interchangeably with functions that iterate over things and that's the main scenario I'd want to check. Pretty much never use ArrayItterators or Traversables.
12

I actually had to add a check for stdClass, as instances of stdClass do work in foreach loops, but stdClass does not implement Traversable:

function is_iterable($var) {
    return (is_array($var) || $var instanceof Traversable || $var instanceof stdClass);
}

5 Comments

All objects can be foreach'd, but doing so is often unintentional.
Not all objects are an instanceof stdClass, but as @Brilliand pointed out, all objects can be foreach'd. In many cases you would be checking to see if you actually want to foreach it, as in when is_array($var) returns true or when $var instanceof Traversable returns true. If you actually do want to run the foreach on anything that can be foreach'd (nothing wrong with that as long as you realize what you are doing and why), then you would be better off replacing the last part of the code with is_object($var)
The next question is why are you using stdClass? Hardly any benefits, many disadvantages.
Update: from PHP7.1 a native is_iterable() function is available.
furthermore, is_iterable(new stdClass) returns false. I think you should mark your answer as deprecated somehow
4

I use a simple (and maybe a little hackish) way to test for "iterability".

function is_iterable($var) {
    set_error_handler(function ($errno, $errstr, $errfile, $errline, array $errcontext)
    {
        throw new \ErrorException($errstr, null, $errno, $errfile, $errline);
    });

    try {
        foreach ($var as $v) {
            break;
        }
    } catch (\ErrorException $e) {
        restore_error_handler();
        return false;
    }
    restore_error_handler();
    return true;
}

When you try to loop a non iterable variable, PHP throws a warning. By setting a custom error handler prior the attempt to iterate, you can transform an error into an exception thus enabling you to use a try/catch block. Afterwards you restore the previous error handler to not disrupt the program flow.

Here's a small test case (tested in PHP 5.3.15):

class Foo {
    public $a = 'one';
    public $b = 'two';
}

$foo = new Foo();
$bar = array('d','e','f');
$baz = 'string';
$bazinga = 1;
$boo = new StdClass();    

var_dump(is_iterable($foo)); //boolean true
var_dump(is_iterable($bar)); //boolean true
var_dump(is_iterable($baz)); //boolean false
var_dump(is_iterable($bazinga)); //bolean false
var_dump(is_iterable($boo)); //bolean true

8 Comments

I ran a slightly modified version on 3v4l.org which works on PHP 5.0+: 3v4l.org/ITNF9. Even stdClass passes on all of them.
Do you know if there's something that your method catches, that this answer doesn't?
@rambocoder any object that doesn't "extend" StdClass nor explicitly implement Traversable. For instance, some PECL libraries, such as PHP Imuttable Extension, use C constructs rather than PHP Objects. Those objects are iterable, but the function above does not recognise them as such, since they aren't based on PHP Object Construct at C level.
There is a new is_iterable() function since PHP7. Take a look to it :)
@Kamafeather that function fails for Classes that don't implement Iterable or for Generic Objects (StdCLass)
|
1

Unfortunately you won't be able to use type hints for this and will have to do the is_array($var) or $var instanceof ArrayAccess stuff. This is a known issue but afaik it is still not resolved. At least it doesn't work with PHP 5.3.2 which I just tested.

1 Comment

ArrayAccess is only about direct access by "array key" syntax, it has nothing to do with iterability.
0

You CAN use type hinting if you switch to using iterable objects.

protected function doSomethingWithIterableObject(Iterator $iterableObject) {}

or

protected function doSomethingWithIterableObject(Traversable $iterableObject) {}

However, this can not be used to accept iterable objects and arrays at the same time. If you really want to do that could try building a wrapper function something like this:

// generic function (use name of original function) for old code
// (new code may call the appropriate function directly)
public function doSomethingIterable($iterable)
{
    if (is_array($iterable)) {
        return $this->doSomethingIterableWithArray($iterable);
    }
    if ($iterable instanceof Traversable) {
        return $this->doSomethingIterableWithObject($iterable);
    }
    return null;
}
public function doSomethingIterableWithArray(array $iterable)
{
    return $this->myIterableFunction($iterable);
}
public function doSomethingIterableWithObject(Iterator $iterable)
{
    return $this->myIterableFunction($iterable);
}
protected function myIterableFunction($iterable)
{
    // no type checking here
    $result = null;
    foreach ($iterable as $item)
    {
        // do stuff
    }
    return $result;
}

Comments

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.