Concise way of using conditional operator

Question

I have this code, where LongMethodWithResult is a method that takes a long time to run:

object o = LongMethodWithResult() == someVal ? LongMethodWithResult() : someOtherResult;

Now the LongMethodWithResult method is evaluated two times, isn't it?

I know I could write a method that uses variables to store the result of the long method, something like this:

public static object ConciseConditionalOperator(object a, object b, object c)
{
    return a == b ? a : c;
}

But I would be interested in whether there is a best way of doing this, or some functionality served by C# or the .NET.

Any ideas are welcomed!

In your case can't you do object o = LongMethodWithResult() == someVal ? someVal : someOtherResult; ? — KMoussa
– KMoussa, Commented Dec 5, 2016 at 10:00
I would as a rule of thumb limit the use of conditional expressions to simple logical expressions without side-effects which trigger a choice between two values. K&R's typical example is choosing between a a plural s and an empty string when they print a text, depending on a number being != 1. — Peter - Reinstate Monica
– Peter - Reinstate Monica, Commented Dec 5, 2016 at 10:07
To avoid @PeterB's (still insightful) shortcut you could ask for a relation other than identity, e.g. LongMethodWithResult() <= someVal ? ... — Peter - Reinstate Monica
– Peter - Reinstate Monica, Commented Dec 5, 2016 at 10:11
@KMoussa and @Peter A. Schneider you are true, ok, let's say the condition is LongMethodWithResult() <= someVal — florien
– florien, Commented Dec 5, 2016 at 10:22

Peter B · Accepted Answer · 2016-12-05 10:21:50Z

5

In this specific case you could use this:

object o = LongMethodWithResult() == someVal ? someVal : someOtherResult;

If you prefer a different notation, or if you want to avoid specifying someVal twice, then you could create an Extension method (in a static class):

public static T IfEqualThenElse<T>(this T valueToCheck, T value1, T value2)
    where T : System.IEquatable<T>
{
    return valueToCheck.Equals(value1) ? value1 : value2;
}

Usage:

var o = LongMethodWithResult().IfEqualThenElse(someVal, someOtherResult);

edited Dec 5, 2016 at 10:21

answered Dec 5, 2016 at 9:59

Peter B

24.7k5 gold badges42 silver badges94 bronze badges

Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

Comments

Thorsten Dittmar · Accepted Answer · 2016-12-05 10:14:22Z

1

Generally you are right. In your example, the LongMethodWithResult is executed twice. To avoid that, you need to first store the result of LongMethodWithResult:

var result = LongMethodWithResult();
object o = result == someVal ? result : someOtherResult;

As Peter B said in your answer, the example you provided is a special case where you don't need that, as when LongMethodWithResult()'s result equals a value you already know, there's no need to call it again. You can just return the value you already know.

However, oftentimes the following is necessary:

var result = LongMethodWithResult();
object o = result == null ? defaultResult : result;

You can, however, replace the last construct with a simple:

object o = LongMethodWithResult() ?? defaultResult;

edited Dec 5, 2016 at 10:14

answered Dec 5, 2016 at 10:08

Thorsten Dittmar

56.9k10 gold badges95 silver badges145 bronze badges

9 Comments

Peter - Reinstate Monica Over a year ago

... and for the latter C# offers the elegant object o = LongMethodWithResult() ?? defaultresult;.

Thorsten Dittmar Over a year ago

@PeterA.Schneider Yes I was going to write that but go a call from a customer.

Peter - Reinstate Monica Over a year ago

Bloody distractions from the important stuff ;-).

Thorsten Dittmar Over a year ago

Yeah, I cut him off, too. Couldn't concentrate on him anyway. :-D

florien Over a year ago

Thanks for the conclusion! Further considering, do you thing it'd be useful if C# allowed a syntax something like (a, b)?: c, where a and b could be the result of two long-running methods, and the expression would be the same as a == b ? a /*or b*/ : c?

|

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

Concise way of using conditional operator

2 Answers 2

Comments

9 Comments

Your Answer

Hot Network Questions

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

2 Answers 2

Comments

9 Comments

Your Answer

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Related