1

I am trying to implement a simplex algorithm following the rules I was given at my optimization course. The problem is

min c'*x    s.t.
    Ax = b
    x >= 0

All vectors are assumes to be columns, ' denotes the transpose. The algorithm should also return the solution to dual LP. The rules to follow are:

rules

Here, A_J denotes columns from A with indices in J and x_J, x_K denotes elements of vector x with indices in J or K respectively. Vector a_s is column s of matrix A.

Now I do not understand how this algorithm takes care of condition x >= 0, but I decided to give it a try and follow it step by step. I used Matlab for this and got the following code.

X = zeros(n, 1);
Y = zeros(m, 1);

% i. Choose starting basis J and K = {1,2,...,n} \ J
J = [4 5 6]  % for our problem
K = setdiff(1:n, J)

% this while is for goto
while 1
    % ii. Solve system A_J*\bar{x}_J = b.
    xbar = A(:,J) \ b

    % iii. Calculate value of criterion function with respect to current x_J.
    fval = c(J)' * xbar

    % iv. Calculate dual solution y from A_J^T*y = c_J.
    y = A(:,J)' \ c(J)

    % v. Calculate \bar{c}^T = c_K^T - u^T A_K. If \bar{c}^T >= 0, we have
    % found the optimal solution. If not, select the smallest s \in K, such
    % that c_s < 0. Variable x_s enters basis.
    cbar = c(K)' - c(J)' * inv(A(:,J)) * A(:,K)
    cbar = cbar'

    tmp = findnegative(cbar)
    if tmp == -1  % we have found the optimal solution since cbar >= 0
        X(J) = xbar;
        Y = y;
        FVAL = fval;
        return
    end

    s = findnegative(c, K)  %x_s enters basis

    % vi. Solve system A_J*\bar{a} = a_s. If \bar{a} <= 0, then the problem is
    % unbounded.
    abar = A(:,J) \ A(:,s)

    if findpositive(abar) == -1  % we failed to find positive number
        disp('The problem is unbounded.')
        return;
    end

    % vii. Calculate v = \bar{x}_J / \bar{a} and find the smallest rho \in J,
    % such that v_rho > 0. Variable x_rho exits basis.
    v = xbar ./ abar
    rho = J(findpositive(v))

    % viii. Update J and K and goto ii.
    J = setdiff(J, rho)
    J = union(J, s)
    K = setdiff(K, s)
    K = union(K, rho)
end

Functions findpositive(x) and findnegative(x, S) return the first index of positive or negative value in x. S is the set of indices, over which we look at. If S is omitted, whole vector is checked. Semicolons are omitted for debugging purposes.

The problem I tested this code on is

c = [-3 -1 -3 zeros(1,3)];
A = [2 1 1; 1 2 3; 2 2 1];
A = [A eye(3)];
b = [2; 5; 6];

The reason for zeros(1,3) and eye(3) is that the problem is inequalities and we need slack variables. I have set starting basis to [4 5 6] because the notes say that starting basis should be set to slack variables.

Now, what happens during execution is that on first run of while, variable with index 1 enters basis (in Matlab, indices go from 1 on) and 4 exits it and that is reasonable. On the second run, 2 enters the basis (since it is the smallest index such that c(idx) < 0 and 1 leaves it. But now on the next iteration, 1 enters basis again and I understand why it enters, because it is the smallest index, such that c(idx) < 0. But here the looping starts. I assume that should not have happened, but following the rules I cannot see how to prevent this.

I guess that there has to be something wrong with my interpretation of the notes but I just cannot see where I am wrong. I also remember that when we solved LP on the paper, we were updating our subjective function on each go, since when a variable entered basis, we removed it from the subjective function and expressed that variable in subj. function with the expression from one of the equalities, but I assume that is different algorithm.

Any remarks or help will be highly appreciated.

2
  • Cycling in the simplex method has tons on references (try Google). There are both theoretical and practical methods to handle this. Commented Nov 14, 2018 at 11:21
  • @ErwinKalvelagen It is not about implementing a simplex method but it is about implementing simplex method in this way. I searched Google but could not find this approach. Anyways, I found the answer. Commented Nov 14, 2018 at 15:04

1 Answer 1

1

The problem has been solved. Turned out that the point 7 in the notes was wrong. Instead, point 7 should be

enter image description here

Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

Comments

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.