NSUserDefaults and Conditional Encoding of Custom Objects in an NSArray

Question

I know there are a lot of posts out there concerning the problem of how to archive custom objects in an NSArray or NSMutableArray and save them in NSUserDefaults. Conforming to the NSCoding Protocol and saving to NSUserDefaults isn't problematic and I use NSUserDefaults quite a lot to store the user-submitted data in my app - it mostly contains objects representing a Person (let's call the NSObject subclass "Person") which can have multiple objects of the NSObject subclass "Property" stored in an NSMutableArray. Therefore, the data structure looks like this:

NSMutableArray "persons":
    Person "aPerson":
        NSMutableArray "properties":
            Property "aProperty"
            Property "anotherProperty"
    Person "anotherPerson:
        ...

Archiving and restoring the information was not problematic at first, because both Person and Property conform to the NSCoding Protocol - but now a problem occured which I was not able to solve yet despite those thousands of google requests in the last couple days ;)

Some of the Property objects contain references to other Persons ("Participants", which are linked to the same property and are contained in an NSMutableArray). When I store the whole data to NSUserDefaults using NSKeyedArchiver, I use

[aCoder encodeObject:participants forKey:@"participants"];

in the Property's "encodeWithCoder" method to archive the NSMutableArray "participants" which stores the references to other Person objects. But when I decode those Person objects, they are created new and separated from the Person objects that already exist somewhere else. The NSMutableArray "participants" only contains references, weak links to the Person objects and should therefore conditional encode its content, as one can do with other objects manually in "encodeWithCoder":

[aCoder encodeConditionalObject:anObject forKey:aKey];

When the NSMutableArray gets decoded, it should represent a list of references to already existing Person objects - not completely new ones! The test "aPerson==[[aDecoder decodeObjectForKey:@"participants"] objectAtIndex:0]" is currently returning NO although it had returned YES before the encoding/decoding process has taken place.

I hope my explanation is somehow understandable and you can help me with my problem :) In simple words: How can I conditional encode custom objects contained in an NSMutableArray?

Thank You !

omz · Accepted Answer · 2011-05-15 14:55:28Z

1

If NSMutableArray would use encodeConditionalObject:forKey: for the objects it contains, it would just mean that those objects aren't encoded at all, if they're not encoded unconditionally somewhere else in your object graph. This wouldn't help you in this case (the array would just be empty).

The problem is that you cannot really encode references to objects in memory. An object reference is basically just a pointer to an address in memory. When you start your app the next time and create the very same object (whether by unarchiving or otherwise), it will almost definitely have a different address in memory. There is no way the unarchiver can 'magically' know, which existing object corresponds to the reference it has archived, because the memory address (the object's 'identity') loses all its meaning when you quit your app.

You have to use other means of identifying your objects, such as database row IDs, dictionary keys, etc. and establish the connection of the archived key and the existing object corresponding to that key manually.

edited May 15, 2011 at 14:55

answered May 15, 2011 at 14:16

omz

53.6k5 gold badges133 silver badges141 bronze badges

Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

4 Comments

knl Over a year ago

Hi omz, thank you for your answer :) i probably used "references" in a wrong way - what i ment is that i have some retained Person objects and then simply call [participants addObject:aPerson]. the objects are therefore retained again and stored in the array. given two NSMutableArrays containing exactly the same objects (which are therefore retained twice each), i want to archive them and then restore them to that state again, so that each array contains not only exact copies but even the same objects. i hope that clarifies the problem. if there is no Solution possible, i must use another appr

omz Over a year ago

In that case, you must encode both arrays with the same root object, e.g. in a dictionary that contains both of them.

knl Over a year ago

Hi again, I still haven't been able to solve my problem <.< For what I have tested, the problem seems to be that the Property class tries to (conditional) decode the Person object when that one hasn't finished its initialization yet: In Person's initWithCoder, an array of Properties gets decoded - and each of them tries to decode that same Person object. Is it possible that the object doesn't yet exist in a form that can be referenced by the Properties' conditional decoding because it hasn't finished initWithCode yet? Can someone imagine a solution? :)

jmif Over a year ago

@knl did you ever solve this? Running into the exact same issue now :)

Giles · Accepted Answer · 2017-11-24 13:42:51Z

I had an issue with this too. I have objects that have an array of weak links to other objects. I know all the objects linked to will be encoded, so I just want to make sure I can rebuild the links.

With a single weak link is it possible to use:

aCoder.encodeConditionalObject(thing, forKey: "Thing")

...and if that item has already been encoded from elsewhere, then a reference to that encoded item will be used.

But, what to do if you have an array full of 'conditional' items, where the array needs to be encoded unconditionally?

I ended up wrapping the items I want to link to.

class thingLink: NSObject, NSCoding
{
    weak var thing: Thing?

    init(_ thing: Thing) {
        self.thing = thing
    }

    required init?(coder aDecoder: NSCoder) {
        thing = aDecoder.decodeObject(forKey: "Thing") as? Thing
    }

    func encode(with aCoder: NSCoder) {
        // We encode these conditionally as they must be used elsewhere
        aCoder.encodeConditionalObject(thing, forKey: "Thing")
    }
}

...then I store these in my array which I encode as usual.

aCoder.encode(things, forKey: "Things")

If I move to a database to store things, I think this will help there too, because I will need a separate table to store the links and maintain priority etc.

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

NSUserDefaults and Conditional Encoding of Custom Objects in an NSArray

2 Answers 2

4 Comments

Comments

Your Answer

Hot Network Questions

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

2 Answers 2

4 Comments

Comments

Your Answer

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Related