Control flow migration Error on Angular 18: @switch can only have @case or @default as childre

Question

I tried to migrate to control flow format in my Angular 18 projects in nx workspace. For most of the templates worked perfectly but for one html I'm getting the following error:

 [ngSwitch]: Error: Text node: "
        ◬" would result in invalid migrated @switch block structure. @switch can only have @case or @default as children.

What I did:

run npx nx generate @angular/core:control-flow-migration
Specify my path of component

Here is my full html:

<ng-container *ngIf="!!type; else DeprecatedStructure">
  <ng-container [ngSwitch]="type">
    <ng-container *ngFor="let type of buttonTypes">
      <button
        *ngSwitchCase="type"
        [style.display]="'flex'"
        [style.flexDirection]="iconPosition === 'right' ? 'row' : 'row-reverse'"
        [ngClass]="buttonClasses[type]"
        [disabled]="disabled"
        [type]="htmlType"
        [id]="id"
        [attr.data-test-id]="dataTestId"
        (click)="handleClick($event)">
        <ng-container [ngSwitch]="type">
          <ng-container *ngSwitchDefault>
            <span><ng-template [ngTemplateOutlet]="ButtonContentRef"></ng-template></span>
            <mat-icon
              *ngIf="!!icon"
              class="fl-icon"
              [ngClass]="{
                right: iconPosition === 'right',
                left: iconPosition === 'left'
              }">
              {{ icon }}
            </mat-icon>

            <mat-icon
              *ngIf="!!svgIcon && !icon"
              class="fl-icon"
              [svgIcon]="svgIcon"
              [ngClass]="{
                right: iconPosition === 'right',
                left: iconPosition === 'left'
              }">
            </mat-icon>

            <span *ngIf="loading" class="loading loading-sm"></span>
          </ng-container>

          <ng-container *ngSwitchCase="icon">
            <mat-icon class="fl-icon">{{ icon }}</mat-icon>
            <span *ngIf="loading" class="loading loading-sm"></span>
          </ng-container>
        </ng-container>
      </button>
    </ng-container>
  </ng-container>
</ng-container>

<ng-template #DeprecatedStructure>
  <button
    [class.btn]="!onlyIcon"
    [class.btn-primary]="!onlyIcon && !textButton && !linkButton && !cardButton"
    [class.btn-secondary]="secondary && !textButton && !linkButton && !cardButton"
    [class.btn-destructive]="destructive && !textButton && !linkButton && !cardButton"
    [class.btn-sm]="size === 'small'"
    [class.btn-lg]="size === 'large'"
    [class.btn-floating-primary]="onlyIcon"
    [class.btn-floating-secondary]="onlyIcon && !!secondary"
    [class.btn-floating-destructive]="onlyIcon && !!destructive"
    [class.btn-flat-primary]="textButton"
    [class.btn-flat-secondary]="textButton && secondary"
    [class.btn-flat-destructive]="textButton && destructive"
    [class.btn-plain-primary]="linkButton"
    [class.btn-plain-secondary]="linkButton && secondary"
    [class.btn-plain-destructive]="linkButton && destructive"
    [class.btn-card]="cardButton"
    [class.btn-loading]="loading"
    [ngClass]="className"
    [disabled]="!!disabled"
    [type]="htmlType"
    [id]="id"
    [attr.data-test-id]="dataTestId"
    (click)="handleClick($event)">
    <mat-icon *ngIf="icon && iconPosition !== 'right'" class="fl-icon" [ngClass]="iconClassName">{{ icon }}</mat-icon>
    <span *ngIf="!onlyIcon"><ng-template [ngTemplateOutlet]="ButtonContentRef"></ng-template></span>
    <mat-icon *ngIf="icon && iconPosition === 'right'" class="fl-icon right" [ngClass]="iconClassName">{{
      icon
    }}</mat-icon>
    <span *ngIf="loading" class="loading loading-sm"></span>
  </button>
</ng-template>

<ng-template #ButtonContentRef>
  <ng-content></ng-content>
</ng-template>

halfer · Accepted Answer · 2024-08-09 22:49:51Z

Try manually migrating the code, it's a script, it can't handle all edge case scenarios. We can migrate it, it would look something like below.

default should always be at the bottom of the switch statement, I think it might be a bug. Please note this change I made which deviates from your code, I promoted the case statement to the top in the inner switch statement.

import { Component } from '@angular/core';
import { bootstrapApplication } from '@angular/platform-browser';

@Component({
  selector: 'app-root',
  standalone: true,
  template: `
    @if(!!type; else DeprecatedStructure) {
      @switch(type) {
        @for(type of buttonTypes; track $index) {
          @case (type) {
            <button
              [style.display]="'flex'"
              [style.flexDirection]="iconPosition === 'right' ? 'row' : 'row-reverse'"
              [ngClass]="buttonClasses[type]"
              [disabled]="disabled"
              [type]="htmlType"
              [id]="id"
              [attr.data-test-id]="dataTestId"
              (click)="handleClick($event)">
                @switch(type) {
                  @case (icon) {
                    <mat-icon class="fl-icon">{{ icon }}</mat-icon>
                    @if(loading) {
                      <span class="loading loading-sm"></span>
                    }
                  }
                  @default {
                    <span><ng-template [ngTemplateOutlet]="ButtonContentRef"></ng-template></span>
                    @if(icon) {
                      <mat-icon
                        class="fl-icon"
                        [ngClass]="{
                          right: iconPosition === 'right',
                          left: iconPosition === 'left'
                        }">
                        {{ icon }}
                      </mat-icon>
                    }
                    @if(svgIcon && !icon) {
                      <mat-icon
                        class="fl-icon"
                        [svgIcon]="svgIcon"
                        [ngClass]="{
                          right: iconPosition === 'right',
                          left: iconPosition === 'left'
                        }">
                      </mat-icon>
                    }
                    @if(loading) {
                      <span class="loading loading-sm"></span>
                    }
                  }
                }
            </button>
          }
        }
      }
    }
    <ng-template #DeprecatedStructure>
      <button
        [class.btn]="!onlyIcon"
        [class.btn-primary]="!onlyIcon && !textButton && !linkButton && !cardButton"
        [class.btn-secondary]="secondary && !textButton && !linkButton && !cardButton"
        [class.btn-destructive]="destructive && !textButton && !linkButton && !cardButton"
        [class.btn-sm]="size === 'small'"
        [class.btn-lg]="size === 'large'"
        [class.btn-floating-primary]="onlyIcon"
        [class.btn-floating-secondary]="onlyIcon && !!secondary"
        [class.btn-floating-destructive]="onlyIcon && !!destructive"
        [class.btn-flat-primary]="textButton"
        [class.btn-flat-secondary]="textButton && secondary"
        [class.btn-flat-destructive]="textButton && destructive"
        [class.btn-plain-primary]="linkButton"
        [class.btn-plain-secondary]="linkButton && secondary"
        [class.btn-plain-destructive]="linkButton && destructive"
        [class.btn-card]="cardButton"
        [class.btn-loading]="loading"
        [ngClass]="className"
        [disabled]="!!disabled"
        [type]="htmlType"
        [id]="id"
        [attr.data-test-id]="dataTestId"
        (click)="handleClick($event)">
        @if(icon && iconPosition !== 'right') {
          <mat-icon class="fl-icon" [ngClass]="iconClassName">{{ icon }}</mat-icon>
        }
        @if(!onlyIcon) {
          <span><ng-template [ngTemplateOutlet]="ButtonContentRef"></ng-template></span>
        }
        @if(icon && iconPosition === 'right') {
          <mat-icon class="fl-icon right" [ngClass]="iconClassName">{{
            icon
          }}</mat-icon>
        }
        @if(loading) {
          <span class="loading loading-sm"></span>
        }
      </button>
    </ng-template>

    <ng-template #ButtonContentRef>
      <ng-content></ng-content>
    </ng-template>
  `,
})
export class App {
  name = 'Angular';
}

bootstrapApplication(App);

JSON Derulo · Accepted Answer · 2024-08-09 09:32:05Z

1

As you can read in the error message, @switch can only have @case or @default as children. However in your case something like the following would be generated during migration:

@switch(type) {
  @for (...) {
    @case () {}
  }
}

Which is invalid as per the above statement. Angular cannot automatically fix this issue, as it was legal syntax with [ngSwitch] and *ngSwitchCase, that's why the migration fails. To fix it, you can move the *ngFor before the [ngSwitch]:

<ng-container *ngFor="let type of buttonTypes">
  <ng-container [ngSwitch]="type">
    <button *ngSwitchCase="">
    <!-- ... your other content -->
  </ng-container>
</ng-container>

And afterwards run the migration again.

answered Aug 9, 2024 at 9:32

JSON Derulo

18.9k11 gold badges63 silver badges85 bronze badges

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

Control flow migration Error on Angular 18: @switch can only have @case or @default as childre

2 Answers 2

Comments

Comments

Your Answer

Hot Network Questions

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

2 Answers 2

Comments

Comments

Your Answer

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Related