3

I started to learn OO a few days back, I'm quite OK with procedural coding but obviously that is not enough and I want to become a well versed coder with a lot of experience and knowledge, so first thing to learn completely must be OO followed by the right design patterns I think.

Anyhow, I have one thing where I'm stuck which I don't quite follow...

Static variables... I understand that a static variable doesn't lose it's value even if the containing function is finished executing, and will keep it's value if the same function is executed again, and again etc etc.

But what I don't understand is what exactly can you now assign to a static variable? The manual and also countless question on stackoverflow state you can not assign an expression to a static variable.

So I read the PHP manual, to find out exactly what is considered an expression? The manuals answer is (and I quote):

"In PHP, almost anything you write is an expression. The simplest yet most accurate way to define an expression is "anything that has a value"."

"When you type "$a = 5", you're assigning '5' into $a. '5', obviously, has the value 5, or in other words '5' is an expression"

http://php.net/manual/en/language.expressions.php

Now when you read about variable scope in the manual, they have exactly this example:

    function test()
    {
    static $a = 0;
    echo $a;
    $a++;
    }

So, the manual about variable scopes says static $a = 0; is fine, while the manual about expressions says $a = 5, would be an expression. Which is basically the same thing, just a 0 instead of a 5...

So I'm a bit confused now.

What exactly is an expression now and what exactly can I or can I not assign to static variables? :)

Improve this question

3 Answers 3

Reset to default
7

You cannot initialize a static variable using a non-constant expression. You can assign anything you like to it after it is initialized.

The difference is that static variables are initialized during the parsing phase, i.e. while PHP reads through the source code to figure out what's what. At that stage no code is executed, PHP just reads what you want it to do. Therefore, it will not execute code to initialize the variable.

static $foo = 'bar';

'bar' is a constant value which PHP can easily assign to the variable at parse time.

static $foo = Bar::baz();

Bar::baz() is an expression that needs to run, PHP needs to locate the class, load it if necessary, run the baz() method, which may do all sorts of different stuff... The same for 5 + 3, md5('bar') or anything that requires actual computation. PHP is simply not going to do all this dynamic stuff at parse time. Therefore you cannot initialize a static variable with anything but constant values.

At runtime, you can assign anything you like to a static variable. An often used pattern is this:

static $foo = null;
if ($foo === null) {
    $foo = new SomeObject;
}

This keeps the instance of SomeObject in the static variable, but you cannot initialize the variable with it.

Improve this answer
Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

3 Comments

"You cannot initialize a static variable using an expression" --- this is not completely true. 'foo' is an expression, as well as 42
Ahhhhh, ok that makes a lot of sense! Thanky ou so much that was an eye opener.
Cool, thanks for the update, it's great to have you people give answers here. You guys made my day :)
2

static keyword changes nothing. 0 is still an expression.

You can assign to static only constant values, that have determined value on parsing stage and have no any calculations.

So

static $a = 0;

is valid code;

static $b = $a + 1;
static $c = 1 + 5;

are not.

Improve this answer

4 Comments

Yes, that is the point that confuses me... the manual says you can not assign an expression to a static var, but then shows the above mentioned example, which is an expression according to the manual. So it confuses the heck out of me...
Ok I see, so it has to be a constant and no dynamic value or calculations etc?
@Marc: yep, deceze covered all possible cases better ;-)
Yeah his answer covers it all and made me understand the differences but yours was also great in the sense that it was easy to understand where exactly I went wrong :)
0

You have mixed up apples and oranges here. (Or/and the manual did a poor job explaining them.)

Static variables, as in your question, are not the same as static properies of a class.

See: http://php.net/manual/en/language.oop5.static.php

Improve this answer

Comments

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.